Showing posts with label Doom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Doom. Show all posts

Monday, September 05, 2011

Two Dooms


So, this is a question asked often enough - Dr. Doom - honorable villain, or bastard who will do what he wants and then justifies it as honorable after the fact? There are writers for both sides of the arguement (John Byrne and Chris Claremont, for "Doom is ultimately honorable and actually quite noble in his way." to Mark Waid for "Doom is a liar and a cheat who pretends he is honorable when in fact he's a total fraud"), and both sides are valid. In my opinion, this is a question of nuance and subtlety - which really shouldn't be a surprise given Doom is, even more than a scientist or wizard, a politican and diplomat.




Does Doom have a code of honor? Yes, but it is a twisted one (and even Byrne acknowledged this). A true diplomat, Doom's one to parse his words, his thoughts, even his perceptions, to maintain this code to himself. Keep in mind, the end result of any action doom undertakes should be in the service of Doom. But they must also bring Doom glory within the wider world. One thing Mark Waid did get right is Doom's need for external validation - it's not enough for Doom to kill Reed - he has to bring him down so that the world can see that Doom was always better than Richards. He doesn't just want to conquer the world - he wants the world to acknowledge that it needs him to conquer it.





Once you remove the external audience (i.e. the world stage, and especially the people of Latveria - more on that later), Doom becomes much more dangerous and deceitful - because he's less likely to gain any kind of external validation, he's more likely to betray, to go back on his word, to find a loophole (which he's usually smart enough to build for himself into any agreement). Like any politician, Doom's dealings behind closed doors are always darker and more devious than when he's in the public eye.






Latveria is the key - Doom has a captive audience who hangs on his every word, and it is there that he MUST be honorable and noble and all the things that he needs to convince himself that he actually is. So his actions there, and on behalf of the citizenry (his underlings are another matter - they know what the score is because Doom demands they be competent enough to carry out what he needs them to - so ultimately they respect him, they fear him, but they know what he is. Which is why he kills them if they step out of line). The misstep Waid made (and it was immediately reversed) was taking away Latveria from Doom. Without a nation that loves him, that feeds his need for validation, Doom becomes more dangerous, not less so. Resources don't matter when you're as dangerous as he is.
















Friday, February 04, 2011

Your Moment of Funny


Been Sick since last week. Sorry. Back now. Will get more posts up soon.

Monday, December 13, 2010

Quick Links post


Short and sweet for today, with more for tomorrow.

Jens Altmann, friend of the blog and author of The Coldest Blood and Cowboys and Barbarians (hit the "Fellow bloggers" tag and go find the Amazon links!) has a really cool idea for a Doctor Doom story here. Check it out.


In the "Someone had way too much time on their hands" dept: The Marvel Universe relationship chart. Just try and follow it as best you can.




Friday, November 05, 2010

MASKED Review Part 3

And now a look at the final stories collected in MASKED

Downfall by Joseph Mallozzi is probably my favorite story in this collection - a look at an ex-villain dragged into a final assignment, who learns more about his past than he ever wanted to. Straightforward, smart and snappy, Mallozzi knows how to give us just enough information to make us put together the puzzle by ourselves, and yet hold back enough to let the final reveal be a surprising treat.

Mark Chadobourn offers a novel tale of power, redemption, and betrayal in By My Works You Shall Know Me. While fans of the genre may not find much new here, the plot works along fine, even if only the protagonist is ever fleshed out as a character. However, given the nature of the protagonist and the narration, I believe that was a necessary conceit to make the story work.

Fans of alternate histories, particularly those of a steampunk bent, will find a lot to enjoy in Call Her Savage by Marjorie M. Liu. Liu offers what (to me at least) is a clever twist on a cliche - a reluctant old warrior called back to duty for a last desperate battle. Of course, in this case, neither the old warrior nor the battle are entirely as first advertised. For me at least, my own familiarity with the genre conventions ended up tripping me at least a couple times here, and it's to Liu's credit that it was clearly laid out to mislead jaded fans such as myself.

A bit overly sentimental and threadbare at times, Ian McDonald manages to pull off a nice little story about old age and superpowers and the bond between old foes in Tonight We Fly. While there are few surprises here, it's still a very competent effort that helps ground the fantastical elements in the real world.

This brings us to the final story in this collection, A to Z in the Ultimate Big Company Superhero Universe (Villains Too) by Bill Willingham. Now, Willingham has garned a reputation among comics fan for some of his political beliefs and for some other online comments he has made to fans. Now, I tried to read this story without thinking about those comments, because I think that a work and the personal beliefs of the writer should be separated to give an unbiased opinion of the work itself. In that light, this was a lighthearted, exceptional clever (giving the sub-chapters alphabetical names was a cute and innovative way of helping to give the necessary background on some of the multitude of characters) bit of work that shows that Willingham has an imagination for world-building and new characters that hasn't had a chance to shine in the current climate (at the very least, not since his Elementals days). It's a very successful effort on his part that clearly illuminates his talent.

Unfortunately, it also highlights a couple of his quirks that were not to my taste. While his knowledge of things mythological and fairy tale are prodigious (as one should expect of the co-creator of Fables and the creator of the Elementals) there is something of an over-reliance on the supernatural evident in this work, like all of it. In his defense, this is a minor quibble of mine, but it was one that reminded me why I'm not a regular fan of his. The other item of annoyance is more significant - while it's very clear (particularly in the online comments he's put above) that he's no fan of current "Superhero Decadence" (and I for one, would like to thank him for coining this term), he's not really interested in promoting the more traditional "Silver Age" moral codes either, preferring his own hybrid of the two. While there's nothing wrong with this, it would have been nicer if he had not created such obvious strawmen from both of these camps to deflate in the story. It would have been far better for him to actually offer up his philosophy for the genre's moral core unhindered by comparison, so it could stand on its own merits. That said, I did enjoy this story, as evidenced by the fact that I've spent so long talking about it.

Overall, while there were a few flubs and non-starters, this is an excellent anthology that I would recommend to any genre enthusiasts looking for some more innovation from the superhero genre.



Saturday, July 31, 2010

Villains - How do you like em?


So, here's an important question: Do you think it's important for a villain to be relatable or sympathetic in a superhero story? If so, how much?


Now, I think the answer tends to vary on the story and the character itself: I don't want to find myself sympathetic to say, the Red Skull in a story because at the end of the day, he's a frickin' Nazi. I mean, end of story. I don't think it's a good idea to portray him as even remotely likable or sympathetic.

By the same token, I don't think I can actually get the motivation of someone like Joker, and I'm probably not supposed to, at least most of the time. With some villains, it's better to just think of them as pure evil because it makes it that much more satisfying when they get their heads beat in by the hero. Sounds simple enough, right?


At the same time, I can understand the desire to feed some complexity and nuance into a story. Making Kang sympathetic in Avengers Forever helps to give him depth. It actually elevates not only him and his lunatic schemes, but also the Avengers. By casting Kang in the role of the unstoppable conqueror, a futuristic Alexander, it helps elevate the Avengers to the level of a force of nature, the one thing that for all his power, Kang cannot conquer. Similarly, although I don't see Magneto as a hero, making his cause understandable adds nuance to his schemes and his fight with Xavier, making their rivalry as much about ideology as much as, you know, people hitting each other.


The problem, I think, is when you try to make a character never meant to be sympathetic into one. And I think that's a thing that has happened too frequently these past few years in comics as noir sensibilities, which work best with a sense of moral ambiguity, have muddied the waters of hero and villain.

What do you think?







Friday, August 08, 2008

A Week in the Life of...Dr. Doom

Monday: CURSE RICHARDS! DOOM SHALL DEFEAT HIM AND HIS MEDDLESOME FAMILY ONCE AND FOR ALL. THIS PLAN IS FLAWLESS, FOR IT WAS MADE BY DOOM!

Tuesday: THE PEOPLE OF LATEVERIA SHALL BENEFIT FROM THE SAGE WISDOM OF THEIR BENEVOLENT MONARCH AS HE WISELY IMPROVES THE LAND! AND THEN, I SHALL ANNIHILATE THE ACCURSED RICHARDS WITH MY GREATEST SCHEME!


Wednesday: DOOM WILL USURP THE POWER OF THIS FOOLISH COSMIC BEING WHO SQUANDERS IT ON AFFAIRS NOT WORTHY OF SUCH POWER. DOOM SHALL TAKE THE POWER THAT SHOULD BE RIGHTFULLY HIS, AND USE IT TO CRUSH THE ACCURSED RICHARDS!


Thursday: BAH! SUCH POWER WAS OBVIOUSLY UNWORTHY OF BEING CONTAINED IN THE PERFECTION THAT IS DOOM! I NEED IT NOT TO DESTROY THE ACCURSED RICHARDS! I SHALL SIMPLY USE A PAWN, A PATSY, TO LURE THEM TO MY CASTLE. PERHAPS WHICHEVER HARLOT DELUDED ENOUGH TO WISH TO SPEND TIME WITH THAT AMBULATORY BRICKYARD…..



Friday: DOOM REQUIRES NO PAWNS! PERHAPS THEN, AN ALLY? YES, OF COURSE! NAMOR IS USUALLY QUITE VULNERABLE AT THIS TIME OF THE WEEK…


Saturday: DOOM NEEDS NO ONE! DOOM SHALL NOW DEFY ALL THE LAWS OF SCIENCE AND THE SUPERNATURAL WHEN HE FREES HIS MOTHER FROM THE GRIP OF THE SO-CALLED “DEMON” MEPHISTO!


Sunday: DOOM WILL CONQUER THE WORLD, AND THEN, HE SHALL DESTROY THE ACCURSED RICHARDS!

Wednesday, June 04, 2008

Pick the Best Caption




Three posters go in, but only your favorite comes out! U-DECIDE!


(Also, go to ADD's comic sale. It's a great deal)

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

Doom's (Bad) Day

Because, just about everyone is talking about it. Yeah, Bendis really doesn't have Doom's Voice, does he?

OK, how do we fix this? Well, Could do what everyone else is doing by redialoguing that scene, but really? Been done. So, instead, borrowing an old idea from Chris Bird, and doing Doom's version of the Gettysburg Address

"Fourscore and seven years ago a gaggle of halfwits and the rabble that followed them, rose up against their so-called royalty, an even dimmer collection of unimaginative buffoons, barely the equal of the Accursed Richards! Their conceptions were the meager scribblings of minds lesser than Doom's and thus not worthy of consideration. Even now they wallow in their own inferiority of a civil struggle; such a thing would never occur under the rule of a true leader as Doom! They will spout their mindless prattle like unenlightened apes unable to see the true wisdom of Doom are wont to, and will wail and bleat as the sheep they are as they inter the resources they waste, sacrificed in vain. It is a sad loss, for if all accepted the rule of Doom none of this needless loss would occur; all those whom have been killed would have instead found happy and content lives in the service of the greater good of Doom! But alas, until their leaders submit to the will and wisdom of Doom, they will choke their soil with their own fluids. Those lost souls will be given the greatest tribute of all: they have Doom's sympathy, for they cannot know how they are exploited and debased and made to suffer under such pathetic and pitiful leadership. Like the Accursed Richards, they will not be remembered, save as a minor footnote in the histories. But Doom shall not forget easily, and thus, it is Doom's struggle to complete his task; the creation of a world that knows not hunger, nor sickness nor suffering nor the slightest material discomfort. And surely, for this great work, some minor tribute would be paid to the rightful savior? Is it not good that the servants thank the masters for their generosity? Of course it is such, and of course, tribute WILL be made. The path before you is so clear that even the youngest child can see--that I highly resolve that a world under Doom shall give birth to a paradise, and that above all else, Doom shall endure."

Thursday, March 13, 2008

Posted for pure Undisputed TRUTH



Stings, don't it?





If Doctor Doom, the (literally) iron-fisted tryant hellbent for leather on world domination and killing a man for looking at his homework says you are a prick, than MAN you need to get some good PR FAST

Monday, February 18, 2008

A Typical Week in the Life of...NAMOR THE SUBMARINER!


With of course, a few tangentially related Posters!


Monday: Invade Surface world, shouting “Imperius Rex!” at the top of my lungs




Tuesday: Change my mind about invading when convinced by a human female (most likely Susan Storm Richards). Betrayed by an unstable power-hungry warlord (Note to self; institute some quality controls in military command structure so I stop promoting these guys) and exiled to the surface world.



Wednesday: Join a superteam that isn’t pissed at me for invading the surface world. Flirt with Susan Richards. Attempt to Join the U.N.



Thursday: Get booted off team for being arrogant/flirting with Sue (No one wants a guy on their team who can get their ass handed to them by Reed Richards) and fail to join the U.N.


Friday: Return to Atlantis, find out that they are about to be enslaved/slaughtered by a warlord who betrayed me



Saturday: Defeat Warlord, reclaim throne



Sunday: Rest, Play with Dolphins, beat up sea monsters, get married to an Atlantean only to have her die for no good reason. Swear vengeance on the Surface world

Huh...ain't that funny? We're right back where we started! Go figure.